关于一个句子的疑惑

看到一个非限制性定语从句:She married him,which was unexpected.=She married him, as(was) unexpected.有解释说此句中which、as可互换;但也曾在别的地方看到过同样的句子,却是特别强调此句中不可用as引导从句,只能用which——因为as引导的非限制性定语从句必须应与主句在意义上和谐一致,或表达“情理之中,顺理成章”的意思,不能是负面的,出乎意料的或是与主句逻辑发展趋势相抵触,一定要natural一点,而不能unexpected.
各自有理,到底谁对?
请看清提问再作答,请不要罗列网上现有的大篇幅解释!谢谢!

which与as引导非限制性定语从句的异同
which与as一样,都可以引导非限制性定语从句,它们既有相同之处,也有差别。因此在实际运用中容易混淆。它们的某些用法在高考中也会考查。
一.相同点。
两者引导非限制性定语从句时,可指代主句中的部分或整个句子的内容,在从句中做主语,宾语或表语,位于主句之后有时可互换。
The meeting was put off, as /which was exactly what we wanted.
He was a doctor,as/which I knew from his manner.
不同点
1. as可指其前后主句提到的事实或情况,因此引导的非限制性从句位置比较灵活,as可以放在主句前后,也可插入主句之中;而which引导的非限制性从句只能位于主句之后。
As is known toall, fish can’t live without water.
Air, as we know,is gas.
2.在非限制性从句中,which后的be动词不可省;as而后的be动词可以省略。
She told me shewon the match , which was a lie.
The material iselastic, as (was) shown in the figure.
3. which在非限制性定语从句做主语时可用各类动词做谓语;而在非限制性定语从句做主语时,谓语常用连系动词,如be, seem, become等,一般不用其他行为动词。
He saw the girl,which delighted him.
He didn’t sayanything at the meeting , as/which seemed very strange.
4. 如果主句中叙述的事情与从句所涉及的意向一致,多用as,用以对主句的意义进行补充;如果不一致,就用which
She has married again, as was expected.
He broke the rules again, which was unexpected.
5.如表示“如同。。。那样,按照,正如”含义,常用as,这里as主要起与上下文联系的作用,表达说话人的看法,并指出内容,出处和根据等,常用的结构有as we know(众所周知)asoften happens(正如常发生的那样)as is often the case(情况常常如此)as we all can see(正如我们看到的)be+announced/expected/known/imagined/mentioned/said/shown/reported(正如所。。。)等。这些结构常放句首,偶尔也可以放句中或句末
As is known to all, China is a developing country.
Kate was late forschool , as often happened.
6.在非限制性定语从句中关系代词指代主句中某一个单词时,常用which
My brother enjoyedplaying basketball , which he really plays well.
Beijing , which he was born in, is our capital.
7.在非限制性定语从句中“介词+关系代词(介宾代物)”中关系代词只能用which
The Travel Agency, with which our company has been dealing for several years, has opened for new branches
Air is a mixtureof gases, of which oxgen forms 21 percent.
8.有时用case, point, time, situation或reason等抽象名词来总结主句的内容,可用“介词+ which +抽象名词”构成从句
Ten years of hard work changed her greatly , for which reason he could hardly recognise her at first sight.
The machine may beout of order , in which case it will be repaired at once.
9.在非限制性定语从句关系代词用以代表主句中谓语的整个概念,从句中的谓语动词是否定形式时,常用which
He can write aletter in English, which I can not.
Metal will bearbeating with a hammer, which a stone willl not
10.在非限制性定语从句关系代词代表前面主句中的宾语从句时,常用which
He said he hadpassed the exam , which was untrue.

这些都是教程内容。追问

请问什么教程?

追答

非限定性定语从句
as 与 which 区别

其实我建议你最好翻阅一下语法书。

很多四级教程的语法题上都会讲到。

根据书上所说的,自己综合理解,再加上网上的,你会理解得更好。
因为语法的东西最主要在于理解。

温馨提示:答案为网友推荐,仅供参考
第1个回答  2012-12-26
看到一个非限制性定语从句:She married him,which was unexpected.=She married him, as(was) unexpected.有解释说此句中which、as可互换;但也曾在别的地方看到过同样的句子,却是特别强调此句中不可用as引导从句,只能用which——因为as引导的非限制性定语从句必须应与主句在意义上和谐一致,或表达“情理之中,顺理成章”的意思,不能是负面的,出乎意料的或是与主句逻辑发展趋势相抵触,一定要natural一点,而不能unexpected.
各自有理,到底谁对?
答:做题造句,一定要注意句子的逻辑意思。
She married him, as had been expected. 她嫁给了他,正如大家所估计的那样。
She married him,which was unexpected. 她嫁给了他,这大家可没有想到。
后一句,不能用as,不信你翻译出来试试?本回答被提问者采纳
第2个回答  2012-12-26
As与which引导非限定性定语从句的区别:
1、which引导的从句不能放在主句前,而as引导的从句则既可以放在主句前,也可以放在主句后。
As we all know, he studies very hard. (as 指代整个句子,作宾语,置于句首)
Taiwan is, as you know, an inseparable part of China. (as指代整个句子,作宾语,置于句中)
2、用能做关系代词,as和which都可以指代一个句子,但as有“正如”、“就像”之意,which则没有此含义。
He is a foreigner, as I know from his accent. (as指代一个句子,意为“正如”、“就像”)
3、当从句的谓语动词是be或相当于联系动词的seem, become等时,可用as或which作主语。但当从句的谓语是行为动词时,只能用which作主语。
He liked the girl,as was / seemed natural.
He liked the girl,which delighted him.
第3个回答  2012-12-26
都不准确 应该以下面作为判断标准

as 和which在引导非限制性定语从句时,这两个关系代词都指主句所表达的整个意思,且在定语从句中都可以作主语和宾语。但不同之处主要有两点:
(1) as 引导的定语从句可置于句首,而which不可。
(2) as 代表前面的整个主句并在从句中作主语时,从句中的谓语必须是系动词;若为行为动词,则从句中的关系代词只能用which.。追问

冒昧请问您给的标准2有权威出处吗,因为看到He has made great progress, as / which makes us very happy.这句话

第4个回答  2012-12-26
She married him, which was unexpected. 句中的which指she married him这件事,不能换成as。
She married him unexpectedly.

She married him which was expected.
She married him as expected.
楼主的意思是否说:as引导的非限制性定语从句不能带否定之意?
相似回答