is the man who standing in the crowd wearing a hat your brother ？

Question

站在人群中戴帽子的那个男人是你哥哥吗？ 这个语法对吗？

Answer 1

本句是错句。应该去掉who，并在wearing前加and。或在who后面加is。前者是现在分词短语作定语，后者是定语从句作定语。即
is the man standing in the crowd and wearing a hat your brother ？
is the man who is standing in the crowd wearing a hat your brother ？追问

is the man who is standing in the crowd wearing a hat your brother ？
请问第二句为什么前面is the man 有一个助动词，后面在who后面还要加一个助动词。

追答

第一个is不是助动词而是系动词。第二个is是进行时的助动词。
本句主干是 is the man your brother？

Answer 2

语法上有误，把who去掉，现在分词作后置定语，wearing前➕and，和standing并列。或改为who is standing in the crowd and wearing…

Answer 3

为您解答
不对，定语从句有问题
两种改法
一，
Is the man standing in the crowd and wearing a hat your brother?
去掉who，改成现在分词做后置定语

二，
Is the man who is standing in the crowd and wearing a hat your brother?
从句加上助动词

Answer 4

陈述语序为:
the man (who is) standing in the crowd and wearing a hat is your brother

缩写句即为:
the man is your brother

一般疑问句就是:
is the man your brother

加上修饰主语的那个定语从句就是
Is the man [(who is) standing in the crowd and wearing a hat your brother ?
其中(who is)可省略追问

为什么who后面还要加is啊？ 前面is the man 不是有一个助动词吗？

追答

我的解释里面写了
前面的is 是陈述句变成一般疑问句的be动词前置句首
who is是定语从句的固定搭配
两个不是同一个概念

who is就是连接定语从句作为修饰the man的
其实就是the man is standing in the crowd……

这个就是一个一般疑问句里夹杂了一个定语从句

Is the man [(who is) standing in the crowd and wearing a hat] your brother ?

补充:定语从句结构
先行词(the man)＋关系词(who)＋定语从句(is standing 或者stand)你这里stand 和wear都是进行时态所以要保持一致，既然一致就说明是进行时态，所以前面应该用is 来修饰，因为进行时标准结构就是be＋动词的ing形式也就是be ＋v. ing

Is the man [(who is) standing in the crowd and wearing a hat] your brother ?
这一句我用括号是为了想让你更直观的了解句子结构，如果实际作答是要把括号去掉

如果who 后面你不想＋is，那么standing和wearing的ing都得去掉，且stand 和wear 都要用第三人称单数stands 和wears，因为主语(the man)是三单

如果我讲的你不明白还可以继续问我哦

我讲解的是个人习惯方式，反正你不明白问我就好了

本回答被提问者采纳

Answer 5

口语正确，语法没问题。